a compass with the words chance, success, risk and failure on the face
Robert L. Weiner: Nonprofit Fundraising Technology Consulting
  • Home
  • Clients
  • Resources
    • CRMs and Donor Databases – Vendors
    • CRMs and Donor Databases – Selection and Strategy
    • CRMs and Donor Databases – Implementation
    • CRMs and Donor Databases – Management
    • Development Operations/Development Services/Advancement Services
    • Email Marketing
    • Newsletters
    • Online Fundraising
    • Online Privacy
    • Social Media
    • Spam
    • Technology Planning
    • Hiring Consultants
    • For Consultants
    • Other Resources
  • Robert Weiner’s Blog
  • About
    • Testimonials
    • Articles by Robert Weiner
    • Presentations by Robert Weiner
    • Services
      • Staffing
      • On-Call Advice
  • Contact

Creative credit card donation scam

March 14, 2012 by Robert 66 Comments

Since this scam is on the rebound I’m republishing the following:

A friend forwarded the following description of a scam aimed at a well-known college.  Fortunately, they didn’t fall for it. 

I would like to make everyone aware of a recent situation here that is most likely a scam to launder stolen credit card funds, appearing as a gift.

  • A $9,000 gift is received and approved from an unknown entity (in this case a “Cassandra Harvey”), with Smyrna, GA address, Yahoo email and legitimate phone number.
  • The next day, we receive an email from the donor with the following info: the $9,000 gift amount was a mistake, it should have been $900. The gift was made in memory of the donor’s late mother (never named) who had a wonderful experience at our college. Further, the original credit card from which the gift was made has been closed due to recent suspect activity and could we refund the $8,100 balance back to another credit card.

Comments

  • We were able to refund the money back to the original credit card and immediately notified the credit card company and local police. Upon notifying the “donor” that we can only refund the money back to the original card, she replies that the original account is closed and that we need to use the other card.
  • The scammer had done enough research to use specific references to our college to make it appear genuine, although there was considerable broken English in the emails.
  • With the flurry of gift activity by our gift processing staff and within the context of providing good customer service to our donors, it could have been easy to overlook normal business rules and refund the balance to that other credit card
  • Most likely the originating credit card is stolen, and by having us charge it and then remit most of the funds to another card, we would be “laundering” the funds for the scammer

As if we didn’t have enough to do right now!

Robert

Comments

  1. Amy says

    February 11, 2014 at 2:13 pm

    Our non-profit in San Francisco also just got a suspicious gift of $8100. The donor info was listed with a GA phone number (same as listed above, which is how I found this thread) and a Indiana address.

  2. Amy says

    February 12, 2014 at 12:51 pm

    This is the email and info of the fraudulent “donor”:

    Christopher Mastriano

    Hello ,i made a donation in memory of someone special and dear to my heart
    and i just check my email now and i discover that i donated $8100,i have intention of donating $810 not $8100,am really

    sorry for this silly mistake,

    i will be glad if you can return $7290 to my corporate account with the following details CARD Number: 4285-****-0022-****

    Expiry Date: 05/14 Cvv: ***.

    I will be very glad to hear from you to ask for my full Visa Card Account information.

    For security reason i have to clear some number of my Visa Account number, so when you confirm from your account about my
    mistake i will forward you my full Visa Account.

    i hope to hear from you soon.

    Thanks

    Christopher Mastriano

  3. Katie says

    February 13, 2014 at 7:08 am

    Got Christopher Mastriano’s email as well for $8100. Our credit card processor caught it for us and I found this website in time. We contacted our local police in metro Detroit.

  4. katie says

    February 13, 2014 at 7:10 am

    Our non-profit in Metro Detroit also just got a suspicious gift of $8100. The donor info was listed with a GA phone number (same as listed above, which is how I found this thread) and a North Carolina Address. Our credit card processor flagged it as did I and contacted our local police department. Hopefully these people get caught.

  5. Ned says

    February 18, 2014 at 12:26 pm

    Christie Larson’s fraudster, Davon White, just did it to us as well.

    Hello ,i made a donation in memory of someone special and dear to my heart
    and i just check my email now and i discover that i donated $8100,i have intention of donating $810 not $8100,am really

    sorry for this silly mistake,

    i will be glad if you can return $7290 to my corporate account with the following details CARD Number: 4285-****-0022-****

    Expiry Date: 05/14 Cvv: ***.

    I will be very glad to hear from you to ask for my full Visa Card Account information.

    For security reason i have to clear some number of my Visa Account number, so when you confirm from your account about my
    mistake i will forward you my full Visa Account.

    i hope to hear from you soon.

    Thanks

    Davon White

  6. Sarah says

    February 21, 2014 at 12:01 pm

    So glad to have found this!! We had an $8,100 gift made by Davon White as well to our Rochester, NY nonprofit. The name was suspicious on its own – the gift even more so as it would be a large one for our nonprofit. We have not yet been contacted by the “fraudster”, but I was able to trace the credit card to the business whose address they used to make the gift – and it was in fact their corporate card number, obviously stolen.

    Hope they catch these fraudsters!

  7. Katherine Goldberg says

    March 10, 2014 at 6:27 am

    We just received a gift for $8,300 from a “donor” in Ft. Collins, CO.

    Luckily, they used a similar phone number and when I googled it I found this string!! Thank you everyone who has posted in the past!!

    Kate

  8. Faith Adams says

    March 12, 2014 at 9:37 am

    He hit our organization, too, apparently using a stolen identity and credit card.

    Hello ,i made a donation in memory of someone special and dear to my heart
    and i just check my email now and i discover that i donated $8300,i have intention of donating $830 not $8300,am really

    sorry for this silly mistake,

    i will be glad if you can return $7470 to my corporate account with the following details CARD Number: 4285-****-0022-****

    Expiry Date: 05/14 Cvv: ***.

    I will be very glad to hear from you to ask for my full Visa Card Account information.

    For security reason i have to clear some number of my Visa Account number, so when you confirm from your account about my
    mistake i will forward you my full Visa Account.

    i hope to hear from you soon.

    Thanks

    [name removed by moderator]

    Hope they catch this loser!

  9. Michelle Gorham says

    April 10, 2014 at 7:34 am

    We also just received a “gift” from Christopher Mastriano. The gift was for $8,300 and we haven’t gotten the second call yet, but I am voiding the transaction. I have had one of these before and it’s a scam. Thanks to our gift acceptance portal for helping us. We love Acceptiva.

  10. Dawn says

    April 30, 2014 at 11:13 am

    Just got hit today at a small nonprofit in Boston:

    Hello ,i made a donation in memory of someone special and dear to my heart
    and i just check my email now and i discover that i donated $8300,i have intention of donating $830 not $8300,am really

    sorry for this silly mistake,

    i will be glad if you can return $7470 to my corporate account with the following details CARD Number: 4285-****-0022-****

    Expiry Date: 05/14 Cvv: ***.

    I will be very glad to hear from you to ask for my full Visa Card Account information.

    For security reason i have to clear some number of my Visa Account number, so when you confirm from your account about my
    mistake i will forward you my full Visa Account.

    i hope to hear from you soon.

    Thanks

    [name removed by moderator]

  11. Gina Arlotto says

    June 30, 2014 at 8:17 am

    We just received a donation for $1100 from Davon White using an address at the University of Arizona and the same phone number as noted in above thread. I’ll post later if we receive the follow up from the scammer. Thanks so much for this helpful website.

  12. Gina Arlotto says

    July 1, 2014 at 6:23 am

    And here’s the follow up, just as described. We have a credit card processor, but I am not totally sure who to turn this over to. Thanks for any advice.

    Greetings

    Thanks for mail confirmation sent to me for my Donation made.

    Am Sorry to tell you this, When i receive donation confirmation in my
    e-mail i see that i have made mistake in donation amount by double
    typing and my intended donation amount was just $110.00 and not
    $1100.00.

    Hope you fully understand me of this error and i will like your full
    corporation in solving this matter for me today.

    Kindly refund back my visa Account that was debited for the donation,
    credit back $990.00 out of $1100 back to my Corporate Visa stated :
    Account Number: 4120********** Exp: 0*/20**.

    Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any question, and
    also forward to me a copy of the refund transaction receipt.

    Sorry for the inconvenience that this might have been caused your Organization.

    Kind Regards

    Davon White

  13. Gina Arlotto says

    July 1, 2014 at 6:34 am

    I just read further up the thread, and will contact my credit card processor and let them take over the investigation.

  14. HT says

    July 1, 2014 at 7:38 am

    Our nonprofit also received a donation for $1,100 from Davon White. Two days later we received an email asking us to refund almost of of this gift to another credit card, which he supplied in the email. We had researched the donor and knew it was a scam so we refunded the full amount to the original credit card and filed fraud complaints with Paypal and with http://www.ic3.gov. Paypal alerted us to this government fraud site and per their website “The IC3 accepts online Internet crime complaints from either the actual victim or from a third party to the complainant.”

  15. Maria says

    August 12, 2014 at 11:37 am

    We had an attempt this week in Kalamazoo…

    “Dear Sir/Ma,

    Is a pleasure to be one of this donor to your foundation, your organization was introduced through donor mailing list sent to my mail box.

    Confirmation receipt of donation i made was received but to my surprised i planned to make a donor of $200.00 but mistakenly or typographical error was occurred during this transaction, i made transaction of $2200.00 instead.

    I was deadly amazed when i saw this and i intended to donate $200.00 not $2200.00

    Hopefully you understand what this meant.

    In view of this, I will like you to refund back $2000.00 from $2200.00 donation made in error to my visa Account number stated below:

    A/C Number: 4120********8300

    Exp Date: 06/20**

    Please do contact me if you have any question and copy me refund receipt when you correct the amount.

    I am very sorry for this inconvenience.

    Kind Regards

    Dr. Janet Christopher”

    I hope this scam artist is eventually “deadly amazed” at being caught.
    -Maria

« Older Comments

Trackbacks

  1. Preventing Fraud on our Online Giving Pages says:
    May 18, 2017 at 12:00 pm

    […] credit card scam/fraud attempt that many nonprofits have experiences starts with a very large online gift from an unknown donor. Shortly afterward, an email arrives saying the amount was a mistake (e.g., $7,000 instead of $700) […]

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Site Search

Recent Posts

  • Android factory reset on a Samsung S7: The ugly, the bad, and the good
  • Migrating recurring donors to a new payment processor
  • Idealware’s revised Consumers Guide to Low-Cost Donor Management Systems
  • An Eleven Step Program to Cure Shiny Object Syndrome
  • New book: “Advancement Services: Enhancing Fundraising Success”
  • Robert on the (Internet) radio
  • Robert in the news(paper)
  • What to Do When Technology Isn’t Your Problem
  • Important changes for GiftWorks users
  • Discussion of Donor Data Retention

Blog Posts by Category

Advancement Services Advocacy Alumni Best Practices Blackbaud Cloud Computing CMS Consulting Convio Databases Donor Databases Email Marketing Foundations Fraud Fundraising GMS Grantmaking Hardware IT Management Malware Marketing Microsoft Mobile Communications Nonprofit Management Nonprofit Technology NTEN Online Fundraising Open Source Phishing Privacy Prospect Research Raiser's Edge Salesforce Scam Search Engines Security SEO Social Media Software Spam TechSoup Viruses Web Web 2.0 Wordpress

Footer #Left

This is an example of a widget area that you can place text to describe a product or service. You can also use other WordPress widgets such as recent posts, recent comments, a tag cloud or more.

Footer #Right

This is an example of a widget area that you can place text to describe a product or service. You can also use other WordPress widgets such as recent posts, recent comments, a tag cloud or more.

Copyright ©2017 Robert L. Weiner: Nonprofit Fundraising Technology Consulting

  • Home
  • Clients
  • Resources
    • CRMs and Donor Databases – Vendors
    • CRMs and Donor Databases – Selection and Strategy
    • CRMs and Donor Databases – Implementation
    • CRMs and Donor Databases – Management
    • Development Operations/Development Services/Advancement Services
    • Email Marketing
    • Newsletters
    • Online Fundraising
    • Online Privacy
    • Social Media
    • Spam
    • Technology Planning
    • Hiring Consultants
    • For Consultants
    • Other Resources
  • Robert Weiner’s Blog
  • About
    • Testimonials
    • Articles by Robert Weiner
    • Presentations by Robert Weiner
    • Services
      • Staffing
      • On-Call Advice
  • Contact
This site uses cookies: Find out more.